Back to Blog
Legal7 min

The building WhatsApp group: what you can post and what you can't

Forty-seven members, two hundred messages on a bad day and not one valid decision. Where the legal line sits, and how to keep the group without the trouble.

The building WhatsApp group: what you can post and what you can't
AI-generated image

Forty-seven members, two hundred messages on the day of a leak, and a thumbs-up poll to decide whether the front door gets replaced. The residents' WhatsApp group is at once the place where the whole building finds things out and the one place where nothing can actually be decided.

Worth knowing before the next dispute: no decision taken in a messaging group binds the association. That is what the general meeting, its notice and its minutes are for. The risk runs the other way: the moment the group becomes the channel the building is run through, it stops being neighbours chatting and falls squarely under the General Data Protection Regulation. And the one answering for it is not whoever created the group, but the association as a whole.

A neighbours' chat is not the same as a management channel

The Regulation does not apply to what a person does in the course of a purely personal or household activity, and recital 18 expressly covers social networking and online activity within that context. Neighbours warning each other that the scaffolding is going up, or lending a drill, sit comfortably inside that household exemption.

The catch is that the exemption is read narrowly.

What weighs are the size of the group, the real relationship between the people in it and, above all, whether there is a management purpose behind it. The day the managing agent sets the group up, or the chair uses it to report on service-charge arrears, announce the AGM or coordinate contractors, it is no longer a private conversation: it is data processing carried out to run the building.

From then on the association is the controller, with everything that follows: a lawful basis, information owed to residents, limits on what gets posted and the ability to show it was done properly. No money needs to change hands and no profit needs to be made — a management purpose is enough.

Adding a neighbour to the group is already processing their data

Putting someone in the group means showing their phone number (usually their name and photo too) to forty-six other people, some of whom are simply the family two floors up. Several European data protection authorities have been blunt about it: doing so without the person's consent is unlawful, and the fact that the number sits in the association's records is no licence to share it around. Two awkward but simple rules follow. Nobody can be made to join, and nobody who leaves may end up worse informed for it: if official communication travels by WhatsApp alone, the resident who is not there loses information they are entitled to.

There is also a short list of things that should never surface in a residents' group:

  • Names or flat numbers of owners in arrears, with or without the figure beside them
  • Full minutes and certificates, which carry personal data on the whole building
  • Photos or video of residents, visitors or number plates, even to "document" something
  • Sick notes, medical details or employment issues concerning the caretaker or cleaner
  • Phone numbers and emails of third parties (contractors included) passed on without permission

A note on the law: fines under the Regulation run to 20 million euros or 4 % of turnover, figures written for large corporations that no residential association will ever see. What is realistic is a complaint from one resident to the national authority, followed by an order, internal embarrassment and a modest but real penalty. The sting is not the amount: it is that the association pays, which means everyone does.

What gets decided in the group has not been decided

This is where hands go to heads. An emoji vote can gather thirty residents in favour of a new front door and still approve neither the spend nor the levy: resolutions require a meeting convened in the manner and with the notice each country's law demands, and minutes recording them. Without that there is no decision to challenge, because there is no decision.

It works the same way in reverse. A notice sent through the group does not replace formal service, and an owner who never received it by the proper route has a ready-made argument for undoing what was approved. Convening properly costs an afternoon; re-running a meeting that was struck down costs a quarter.

The trick any seasoned agent applies is never to answer a complaint in the group. If a resident asks about their service charge on WhatsApp, the answer goes back in writing through the formal channel, with proof of sending. Replying in the thread guarantees two things: it disappears into the scroll, and it reappears as a screenshot at the worst possible moment.

How to keep the good part and drop the problem

Banning WhatsApp is not the answer, and would not work anyway. The answer is to separate the two things currently tangled together: neighbours talking, and the building being run.

A split that works at any size:

  • The social group stays alive, holding nobody's data and pretending to decide nothing
  • Association announcements go out on a channel where only the management posts
  • Notices, minutes, charges and complaints travel the formal route, with acknowledgement
  • Every resident gets what concerns them without their phone number doing the rounds

That last point is usually what tips the decision: in a management tool such as Vecinly each matter has its own thread and its own record, and nobody needs anyone's number to stay informed. A messaging group cannot offer that by design — its currency is precisely the phone number.

A printed meeting notice and a delivery receipt on a wooden table, beside a silenced phone
Each thing on its own channel: what binds you travels in writing and leaves a trace.

The residents' group is not the villain. It is an excellent channel for what it is good at: a parcel has arrived, the lift is out. It stops being one when it is asked to serve as meeting, notice board and archive all at once. That combination produces only two things: decisions that count for nothing, and personal data travelling where it should not.

Information is up to date. This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

What can go in the residents' WhatsApp group, why its votes don't count and how to stay GDPR-compliant without losing your channel. A practical guide.

Share article:

Available in 11 languages

Try the specialized platform for your community

Organize maintenance, communication and management easily.